BOSTON (Diya TV) — A federal judge has struck down a Trump administration rule that sought to limit how long international students could remain in the United States. The decision preserves a long-standing immigration policy that allows foreign students to stay in the country as long as they maintain their legal status and make normal progress toward completing their academic programs.
The ruling marks a setback for the Trump administration’s efforts to tighten student visa regulations. It also offers relief to thousands of international students, researchers and professors who feared that stricter time limits could disrupt their education and academic careers.
U.S. District Judge Dennis Saylor of Massachusetts issued the decision Monday. He ruled that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) failed to properly justify its proposed changes. He also found that the agency did not adequately consider the potential impact on students and educational institutions.
In July, the Department of Homeland Security issued a final rule that aimed to replace the existing “duration of status” system. Under the current policy, most international students can remain in the United States throughout their academic programs, provided they follow visa requirements and maintain lawful status.
However, the proposed Trump administration rule would have introduced a four-year limit for most F and J visa holders. The restriction would have applied regardless of the length of their academic programs or research activities.
As a result, students pursuing longer degrees, researchers working on extended projects, and professors needing additional time would have faced new requirements. They would have needed to apply for extensions to remain in the country legally.
The proposal also included other restrictions that could have increased paperwork and uncertainty for international students.
A coalition of education advocacy organizations challenged the rule in August. The groups argued that the administration had failed to provide a reasonable explanation for the changes. They also warned that the restrictions could discourage international students from choosing American colleges and universities.
In his decision, Saylor described the rule as “arbitrary and capricious.” He said DHS failed to properly weigh the policy’s potential benefits against its financial and administrative costs.
Moreover, the judge found that the department did not provide sufficient evidence to support its claims about visa fraud and national security risks.
Saylor also concluded that the proposed restrictions conflicted with congressional intent. He said Congress had created the F-1 visa program to allow and encourage foreign students to pursue education in the United States.
“Put bluntly, DHS is seeking to prevent or discourage the very activity—providing educational opportunities for foreign students in the United States—that Congress sought to permit and encourage,” Saylor wrote.
He added that immigration law does not give DHS broad authority to undermine the student visa program.
The Trump administration has argued that stricter student visa policies would help prevent immigration abuses. Officials have also raised concerns about foreign nationals remaining in the country for extended periods without completing their studies.
Previously, DHS officials said some international students had taken advantage of the existing system by becoming “forever students.”
Following the ruling, DHS referred questions to a social media statement from its general counsel, James Percival. He criticized the decision and argued that the ruling would allow students to remain in the country for decades while taking only one class each semester.
However, the judge’s decision keeps the existing duration-of-status policy in place.
The ruling comes as U.S. colleges and universities face growing concerns about declining international student enrollment.
According to the Institute of International Education, new international student enrollment at American colleges and universities fell 15% this fall compared with the previous academic year.
Miriam Feldblum, president and CEO of The Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, welcomed the court’s decision. Her organization joined the legal challenge and represents a network of 500 college and university presidents and chancellors.
Feldblum warned that the proposed restrictions could have further reduced international student enrollment. She also said the policy could have disrupted students’ academic plans and created additional administrative challenges for colleges.