WASHINGTON (Diya TV) — The American dream is losing its appeal for many Indian Americans, as rising political tensions, economic stress, and immigration hurdles reshape long-held aspirations. A new survey by the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, conducted with YouGov, shows that nearly 40% of Indian Americans have considered leaving the United States. The findings highlight a shift in sentiment within one of the country’s fastest-growing immigrant communities. Once seen as a land of opportunity, the U.S. now feels uncertain for many.
The survey reveals that frustration with U.S. politics is the top reason driving this trend. About 58% of respondents who considered leaving cited political concerns. Many expressed dissatisfaction with the current political climate under Donald Trump.
Around 71% of respondents said they disapproved of how the administration handled key issues such as the economy, immigration,n and foreign relations. Many also pointed to a shift in national rhetoric. Phrases emphasizing “America for Americans” have created a sense of exclusion among immigrant groups. Experts say this tone has made some Indian Americans feel less welcome. The concern is not just about policies but also about belonging. Many respondents reported discomfort with public discourse and growing polarization.
Social factors also play a major role. About 41% of respondents cited personal safety as a concern. While data does not show a sharp rise in violent incidents since 2020, many people report an increase in everyday bias. Respondents said they often avoid sensitive conversations at work or online. Some said they feel less comfortable in public spaces. This subtle but persistent unease is shaping long-term decisions.
For first-generation immigrants and non-citizens, these experiences carry more weight. Many said they worry about their families and future stability. Over time, these concerns add to the desire to seek alternatives outside the U.S.
Economic stress is another major factor. About 54% of respondents pointed to the high cost of living as a key concern. Cities like San Francisco, Seattle and New York City have become increasingly expensive. Rent for a one-bedroom apartment in these urban centers ranges between $3,000 and $5,000 per month. The cost of raising a child now exceeds $300,000. These figures make long-term settlement difficult for many middle-class families.
Inflation and job security also weigh heavily. About 21% of respondents cited inflation as a concern, while 17% worried about job stability. Many professionals in the tech sector and other industries face uncertain job markets. These economic pressures are forcing families to rethink their future. Some now consider returning to India or moving to other countries with lower living costs.
The U.S. immigration system continues to be a major source of frustration. Long visa backlogs and delays in green card processing affect a large number of Indian professionals. Many skilled workers live in the U.S. for years on temporary visas. Despite contributing to the economy, they face uncertainty about permanent residency. Recent visa bulletins have reinforced the idea that green cards remain out of reach for many.
This lack of stability affects both personal and professional decisions. Families often delay major life plans due to unclear immigration status. Over time, this uncertainty pushes some to explore other options.
The survey also shows a shift in political alignment among Indian Americans. Fewer people now identify strongly with one political party. Since 2020, support for Democrats has declined, while Republican support has remained stable.
About 30% of respondents now identify as independents. This marks a growing trend toward issue-based decision-making. Voters are focusing more on practical concerns such as safety, jobs, and economic stability. Analysts say this shift reflects broader changes within the community. Indian Americans are no longer voting as a unified bloc. Instead, they are responding to current challenges and personal experiences.
The U.S. is home to more than 5.2 million people of Indian origin. This community has long played a key role in sectors like technology, healthcare and education. However, the survey suggests a turning point.
