SACRAMENTO, Calif. (Diya TV) — The Berkeley man known as the “NorCal Rapist” is now eligible for elder parole under newer California laws, a development that has reopened deep wounds for his victims and raised serious public safety concerns.
The man, Paul Waller, terrorized women across Northern California for 15 years. A judge once sentenced him to nearly 900 years in prison. Recent legal changes reduced that sentence and made him eligible for possible release in the future.
Waller was convicted in 2020 on 46 felony counts, including rape, burglary, and kidnapping. The crimes occurred across six Northern California counties between the late 1970s and early 1990s. DNA evidence eventually linked him to the assaults. A Sacramento County judge sentenced Waller to 897 years to life. The sentence brought relief to victims who believed he would never walk free. That certainty changed this week.
During Waller’s appeal, one charge was reduced from kidnapping to false imprisonment. The change required resentencing. Judge James Arguelles, who also presided over the original trial, reduced the sentence by 39 years. Waller now faces 858 years to life in prison. The reduction did not free him. It did, however, make him eligible for California’s elder parole program.
California law allows inmates age 50 and older to seek elder parole after serving at least 20 years in prison. Lawmakers created the program to reduce prison costs and address health issues among aging inmates. Waller is 65 years old. He must serve 20 years of his sentence before he can ask the parole board for release. That could happen in about 14 years. Assistant Chief District Attorney Chris Orr, who prosecuted Waller, criticized the policy.
“There’s some irony,” Orr said. “Victims of elder abuse must be 65. But someone who commits multiple rapes can qualify as elderly at 50.”
Two of Waller’s nine known victims attended the resentencing hearing at the Sacramento County Courthouse. Both were attacked in the early 1990s. Nicole Ernest-Payte, believed to be Waller’s first victim, spoke publicly about her experience. She said she remembers the attack every day. She described waking up to a masked man in her home. He held a gun to her head. He wrapped an arm around her neck. Ernest-Payte said Waller’s arrest brought her peace after decades of fear.
“I thought it was over,” she said. “I thought he was gone forever.”
The recent court action reopened old trauma.
“It’s intrusive,” she said. “It brings everything back.”
Judge Arguelles did not hide his frustration during the hearing. He questioned how Waller could ever be considered safe.
“If he’s not a danger to society, then I don’t know what a danger to society is,” Arguelles said in court.
The judge said he believes Waller would harm more victims if released. Arguelles also criticized state lawmakers. He said current laws focus too much on defendants and not enough on victims.
Prosecutors said Waller broke into women’s homes late at night. He used weapons and threats. He planned his attacks carefully. When police arrested him in 2018, he was 58 years old. Officers said he carried a backpack filled with tools used for sexual assaults.
“That shows who he is,” Ernest-Payte said. “How elderly was he then?”
Elder parole does not guarantee release. The parole board must still decide whether an inmate poses a public risk. Victims have the right to attend hearings and submit statements. Still, the possibility of Waller’s release has shaken survivors and sparked debate over California criminal justice reform. For now, Waller remains in state prison. His defense attorney declined to comment after the hearing. For victims, the fear is no longer abstract. It has a timeline.